Dear Christian Sisters,
Could we talk to you right out of our hearts for a few minutes?
It is awkward for us to talk about something of this nature, in person, so we thought we would write our feelings. And in our past experience, those men who have been brave enough to speak are sometimes met with some less than desirable responses. We are young men who have been saved by grace and been given the Holy Spirit. We desperately want to live for Christ and not follow the ways of the world or even our flesh. Since we have committed ourselves to our Lord Jesus, we believe we should live “holy” lives as the Scriptures command us (1 Pe 1:16). After all, our bodies are the temple, the sanctuary, the place where the “Holy” Spirit lives and makes His home (1 Cor 3:16; 6:19).
You know women, but we know men. We know what we think, what we talk about, what we want, and what we look for. And it differs depending on our relationship with God. We know that men and women are affected and respond differently. We have different desires and priorities. Our eyes and minds react very differently to some things than yours do. Generally speaking, we realize that women are primarily stimulated or turned on by “touch,” maybe that’s why 1 Corinthians 7:1 (NASB) says, “It is good for a man not to touch (hapto, also used in 2 Cor 6:17; Col 2:21; 1 Jn 5:18) a woman.” Though this could be changing as our culture continues to be more and more visual. However, did you know that guys are turned on by “sight” (cf. Prov 7:10, notice the attention to the clothing)? We are aroused sexually in the same way aroused by mere “sight.” Just as Nancy DeMoss says, ”What a man’s touch is to a woman, the sight of a woman is to a man.” It isn’t disgusting, perverted, or wrong; it is wonderful and good! Especially in marriage! It is how God made us. However, it’s how we handle these differences that separate a Godly man from a worldly man. So since we desperately want to follow hard after God, could we kindly and respectfully ask you to help us with this insofar as you can? This is not to absolve us of any responsibility, but asking for help.
As you may know, a worldly man, even a carnal Christian or backsliden Christian man, won’t care or control himself whenever he looks at women. He may lust any time and every time regardless of clothes. They have no problem with women who wear clothes that show off skin, like boxers, high or low cut shirts, low rise jeans, and “cute” little swim-suits or bikinis. He’s a fan of tight-fitting shirts and pants that show off your form, he thinks they’re fine! He’s a really nice guy and sees you mainly for your body. However, we are not them. We are trying to be godly, Christian men who honor God with everything we do. Just like Job, we have already made a covenant with eyes (Job 31:1), so how can we ogle at women and not feel some sort of conviction from the Holy Spirit? However, when we see women who are dressed in a suggestive, revealing, provocative, teasing, and/or tantalizing manner regardless of their intentions, our sexual desires are aroused too and our bodies are affected and sometimes we stumble as a result (cf. Matt 18:6). It is not as though we are looking for these women are already everywhere. We use everything at our disposal and try to protect our eyes and mind. We absolutely abhor being around women that disrespect us and our struggles by wearing inappropriate attire.
So, if you will, let us be absolutely candid, and let us give you some examples of what we are referring to: women who are wearing a blouse that barely meets the waist of their slacks and some of their skin shows while they are moving around, or simply while they are walking, sitting, kneeling, or raising their hands, our minds are geared to wonder what more of their body would look like further up. Another example is when a woman wears low-cut tops which are in any degree revealing, or when they bend over (esp. when they bend at the waist and not the knees) and they are revealing themselves, this again causes us big problems in the flesh. Or for some of us, if the back is out of their top, we automatically think that they do not have the undergarment on, and the Spirit and the flesh begin to fight again. Or when we see any glimpse of undergarments, such as straps and the like, we have trouble. And by far, white slacks/skirts are the worst! Do you know that men can see your panties through white khakis?
This causes our bodies to respond biologically, and suddenly we are fighting a war in our minds and bodies. And that war of lust is continuing often long, even hours/days after you are gone. We hate this, because we want to think pure thoughts (Phil 4:8). There is no excuse for lust. And while we try to take every thought captive (2 Cor 10:5), it would be better for us not to have to take so many thoughts captive as a result of what we see. Yes, we try not to look. We actively look the other way. We have learned to bounce our eyes and star at the floor and admiring the beauty of the carpet or rocks or whatever we can rest our eyes. Some of us will just leave the room. All we are asking is for some help. Yes, there are tons of billboards, advertisements, and the like that we already need to fight. So please, will you help us? You can either help us succeed morally or can put temptation in our path making it difficult for us to overcome.
We know that you want to glorify God. We know that you want to please God. And, we know that you have the Holy Spirit if you believe in Jesus. So we listen to that the still small voice of the Holy Spirit that speaks to you and nudges you when it is too tight, too short, too low, or too revealing. Will you listen to that voice? For the Scripture says, “Do not quench the Spirit” (1 Thess. 5:19). It must be tough to want to be stylish and yet want to be modest. Some of you have husbands, roommates, sisters, and brothers. If possible, ask a guy, not that you need a man’s approval or anything; for we all have our blinders. Will you commit to always ask someone (if available) honestly, “How do I really look?” (i.e., could I cause someone stumble at my appearance? See Mark 9:42) before going out, especially to church. If you are single and don’t have any one to ask, ask yourself in front of a mirror, “Would I want my boyfriend/fiance [if you don't have one pretend that you do] to see another girl dressed like I am?” Or, “If I saw my my boyfriend/fiance [if you don't have one pretend that you do] looking at a girl dressed like this would I think he’s lusting/ogling after her?” If so, change. And if you have done everything you need to do with a clear conscience, then go however you are dressed.
Women, while we would like to come among our Christian sisters and not have to fight and struggle in the flesh, we know we must always be on guard. While we do not need to have to wrestle in the flesh at church or at church activities, we know that at church is where we are most targeted by the devil and his cohorts. We men, whether young, old, single or married, are faced with this every day among women of the “world” who love to wield the power of attraction and seduction and who use their bodies to those ends. While we would like to have some rest for our souls and eyes, we know that we can never rest. Not because of you per se, but because we know we cannot control what our eyes see initially. The Bible is clear for it says, “Do not love the world nor the things in the world. If anyone loves the world, the love of the Father is not in him” (1 John 2:15).
And you may be thinking, “Well, doesn’t the Bible say, ‘God sees not as man sees, for man looks at the outward appearance, but the LORD looks at the heart’? So if God looks at my heart, then it doesn’t matter what I wear, right?” 1 Samuel 16:7 is speaking directly to your heart, but the fact is if your heart is pure, your outward appearance will be modest. Women can be fashionable and modest at the same time.And yes, while we really don’t know how difficult it is for you to find stylish and well-fitting clothes, please know that we recognize it. And also remember 1 Samuel 16:7, God looks at your heart and is constantly looking for women like you (2 Chr 16:9). He notices that you are looking to the interests of others (Phil 2:3-4) as Jesus did (Phil 2:5-11). For the modesty that we are requesting is a matter of your heart, not necessarily your wardrobe.
To be honest, we respect you more when your appearance is modest, as the Scripture commands in 1 Timothy 2:9. And someone who actively pursues modesty by holding their shirt down as they bend over or stoop down is attractive because it shows the beauty of their heart. We really do not want the kind of girl who dresses provocatively, for we know that if we marry her, she will still be that way in the presence of other men once we are married. And so think about it like this: “What kind of man do you want? Answer me with your clothes.” The way you show it will attract either a worldly one or a godly one.
Thank you, dear Christian sisters, for hearing our hearts on this subject. Now that we have conveyed the truth of the matter to you, we hope that you act responsibly before God in regards to this truth. We really are “our brother’s keeper” (Genesis 4:9). We know that there is a “cult of conformity” in our generation, but we as Christians “not to conform to this world” (Rom 12:1-2). Please, do not say, “I don’t care,” but help us in these last days to live as close to Jesus as we can, and as you strive to help us, you walk more like Jesus (Phil 2:3-11). Thank you so much.
Sincerely,
Your Christian Brother